Oy Vey, My Back Hurts: Running an Insurance Agency When Your Body Won't Cooperate

By Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman7 min read

Hosts of The Insurance Dudes Podcast — 1,000+ episodes helping insurance agents build elite agencies

Oy Vey, My Back Hurts: Running an Insurance Agency When Your Body Won't Cooperate

There's a specific kind of morning that every agency owner dreads. The alarm goes off. You swing your legs over the side of the bed. And something in your lower back sends a signal to your brain that roughly translates to: "We're not doing this today." Except you are doing this. Because policies don't write themselves, claims don't manage themselves, and your team doesn't lead itself just because your L4 vertebra decided to go on strike.

Running an insurance agency through physical pain is one of those topics that doesn't make it into the business books or the motivational seminars. It's too mundane, too unglamorous, too human. But it's real, it's common, and how you handle it says more about your long-term success as an agency owner than any production metric ever could.

The Entrepreneur's Body Problem

Here's the thing nobody tells you when you sign up for agency ownership: the stress of running a business takes a physical toll that compounds over years. The desk hours. The phone posture. The stress eating. The sleep deprivation during heavy production months. The cortisol from managing staff problems, carrier issues, and client emergencies simultaneously. Your body keeps a running tab, and eventually it presents the bill.

Back pain is the most common version, but it shows up everywhere, chronic headaches, digestive issues, shoulder problems, fatigue that sleep doesn't fix. The entrepreneurial hustle culture treats these as badges of honor or minor inconveniences to power through. Neither response is useful. Treating pain as a badge of honor means you never address the root cause. Treating it as a minor inconvenience means you operate at 60% capacity while telling yourself you're at 100%.

The honest truth is that physical pain degrades every business function. Your sales calls are worse because you're distracted. Your team leadership is worse because you're irritable. Your strategic thinking is worse because chronic pain literally reduces prefrontal cortex function. An agency owner operating through unmanaged pain isn't being tough, they're voluntarily handicapping their business.

The Perseverance Paradox

And yet. The agency doesn't stop because your back hurts. The phones still ring. The renewals still process. The team still needs direction. There's a legitimate tension between "take care of your body" and "your business requires your presence," and pretending that tension doesn't exist isn't helpful.

The resolution lives in what you might call strategic perseverance: showing up when you must, modifying how you show up, and building systems that reduce how much you personally must do on any given day.

Showing up when you must means distinguishing between discomfort and danger. A stiff back is discomfort, you can work through it with modifications. A back injury that worsens with activity is danger, pushing through it creates a longer recovery and a bigger business disruption down the road. The agents who tough out dangerous pain and end up needing surgery lose more production in the long run than the agents who take three days off early and come back healthy.

Modifying how you show up means getting creative with your work environment. Standing desks. Walking meetings instead of sitting meetings. Phone calls from a reclining position instead of hunched over a desk. Delegating in-person meetings when you're physically compromised and handling them via video call instead. These aren't signs of weakness. They're operational adaptations that maintain productivity while respecting physical limitations.

Building systems that don't require your physical presence is the long-term solution. If your agency falls apart when you can't physically show up for three days, you don't have a business, you have a job that requires your body in a specific chair for a specific number of hours. The back pain is actually doing you a favor by revealing this structural vulnerability before something more serious forces the same reckoning.

The Systems Fix for Physical Fragility

Every time your body forces a slowdown, treat it as a systems audit. Ask: what couldn't happen today because I wasn't at full capacity? Make a list. Then spend your recovery time building the process, delegation plan, or automation that would handle each item without you.

Client called with a service question only you could answer? Document the answer in a knowledge base your team can access. Prospect needed a callback that only you could make? Train a team member on that product line so they can handle the consultation. Marketing content didn't get posted because you manage it personally? Set up a content calendar with scheduled posts that run automatically.

The agency owners who build these systems in response to physical limitations end up with more resilient businesses than the ones who never had a reason to delegate. Your back pain, as miserable as it is, might be the best business consultant you never hired, because it forces you to build an agency that doesn't depend on your personal presence for every function.

The Prevention Conversation Nobody Wants to Have

This needs to be said even though it's boring: the best way to manage physical challenges while running an agency is to prevent them. And prevention for entrepreneurs isn't complicated, it's just consistently deprioritized.

Move your body for 30 minutes a day. Not as a fitness goal. As a business investment. The ROI on daily exercise in terms of energy levels, cognitive function, stress management, and injury prevention is higher than any marketing spend you'll ever make.

Get a decent chair. The $200 you're saving by using that conference room reject isn't saving you anything when you factor in the chiropractor visits and the reduced productivity from chronic discomfort.

Sleep seven hours. Not six. Not "I'll catch up on the weekend." Seven hours, consistently. Sleep deprivation is the single most common contributor to the physical breakdown that agency owners experience, and it's the easiest one to fix.

Manage stress proactively instead of reactively. That means boundaries on work hours, delegation of tasks that drain you, and some form of regular stress discharge, exercise, time with friends, hobbies, anything that isn't work and isn't a screen.

What This Means for Your Agency

If you're currently dealing with physical pain, do three things this week.

First, see a professional. Not Google. A doctor, a physical therapist, a chiropractor, someone who can assess whether you're dealing with discomfort you can manage or an injury that needs treatment. Agency owners are notoriously bad at seeking help because they're used to figuring everything out themselves. Your musculoskeletal system isn't a carrier contract. Get expert input.

Second, identify the three tasks that suffer most when you're physically compromised. For each one, write the first step toward making that task executable by someone other than you. You don't have to implement all three this week. Just document the gap.

Third, make one physical health investment today. Buy the standing desk converter. Schedule the appointment. Set the alarm 30 minutes earlier for a walk. One action, today. Not Monday. Today.

The Bottom Line

Your body is the infrastructure that everything else runs on, your agency, your team, your family, your life. When it sends you pain signals, it's not being inconvenient. It's giving you information. The agents who listen to that information, adapt their operations, and invest in prevention build agencies that last. The ones who power through indefinitely build agencies that collapse when their body finally forces the issue on its own terms instead of theirs.


Catch the full conversation:

Level up your agency:

Listen to The Insurance Dudes Podcast

Get more strategies like this on our podcast. Available on all platforms.

Related Episodes