Why Your Insurance Agency Needs More Bad Ideas: Jeremy Utley on Ideaflow and Innovation
Hosts of The Insurance Dudes Podcast — 1,000+ episodes helping insurance agents build elite agencies
Every insurance agency owner has had the experience: you need a breakthrough in your marketing, your hiring process, or your client retention strategy, and you can't come up with one. The ideas that come to mind feel recycled, incremental, or just wrong. You know you're missing something but can't see what it is. Jeremy Utley's research on innovation has a precise explanation for why this happens, and a counterintuitive prescription for how to fix it.
Utley is one of the world's leading experts on applied innovation and co-author of "Ideaflow: The Only Business Metric That Matters." His argument is simple and radical: the reason most people and organizations can't produce great ideas on demand is that they're trying to generate quality directly, rather than generating volume first. That's not just inefficient, it's neurologically impossible.
Jeremy Utley's Research and the Ideaflow Breakthrough
Jeremy Utley spent years studying how innovation actually works inside organizations that do it consistently, from established tech giants to scrappy startups to companies that have maintained creative momentum across decades. The pattern he and his co-author extracted from that research is the principle of ideaflow: the rate at which an individual or team generates ideas.
The conventional model of creative problem-solving looks like this: identify the problem, think carefully, produce a good solution. The assumption embedded in this model is that quality comes from careful, deliberate thought. Utley's research turns this assumption on its head. In practice, the organizations and individuals that consistently produce breakthrough solutions do so not by thinking more carefully, but by generating more ideas, including, critically, more bad ideas.
The underlying mechanism is probability. If you need one great idea and you generate three, the probability of hitting the great one is low. If you generate 30, the probability is much higher, and the quality of the best ideas improves as well, because having more options forces more creative comparison and synthesis. The great idea rarely arrives as the first idea. It usually emerges somewhere in the middle of the list, often as a recombination of earlier ideas that were each insufficient on their own.
For insurance professionals, this framework directly challenges a cultural habit that's pervasive in the industry: the tendency to evaluate ideas too early. Most agencies have an implicit culture where new ideas are quickly tested against the question "will this actually work?", and because most ideas can't survive that scrutiny in their early, undeveloped form, most ideas get killed before they have a chance to develop into something useful. The result is a culture that feels conservative, uncreative, and stuck.
Utley's prescription is to separate ideation from evaluation, to create explicit space for generating ideas without judgment, where the only criterion is volume and novelty. That separation is uncomfortable in a culture that prizes practicality. It requires a temporary suspension of the critical faculty that feels like letting your guard down. But it's the suspension that makes breakthrough possible.
Key Insights on Building an Innovation Practice in Insurance
The metric that reveals your agency's innovation health is ideaflow itself, how many new ideas are generated in a given time period, not just how many are implemented. Most agencies have an extremely low ideaflow, not because they lack intelligent people, but because their structures and cultures actively suppress idea generation. Meetings focused on reporting and accountability, not exploration. A management style that quickly critiques new suggestions. A bias toward incremental changes over novel approaches. These patterns starve the creative process.
Disruptive innovation doesn't require genius, it requires willingness to entertain "stupid" ideas. Utley draws on research from design schools and innovation labs showing that some of the most valuable breakthroughs started as ideas that seemed obviously bad or naive. The prescription is not to implement obviously bad ideas, but to not kill them immediately, to let them stay in play long enough for their hidden potential to become visible. In an agency context, this might mean a brainstorming meeting where the facilitator's explicit job is to prevent evaluation for the first half of the session.
The innovation portfolio principle: not every idea needs to be transformational. Utley's framework distinguishes between incremental improvements, significant enhancements, and disruptive innovations, and argues that a healthy organization cultivates all three simultaneously. Most insurance agencies over-invest in incremental improvement (tweaking existing processes) and under-invest in exploration (genuinely new approaches). Rebalancing toward more exploratory experimentation, even small, low-stakes tests of new ideas, builds the organizational muscle that produces bigger breakthroughs over time.
The time and space for innovation don't appear spontaneously, they have to be designed. Utley's most actionable recommendation for leaders is to explicitly schedule creative time that is protected from operational demand. Not a quarterly offsite, a regular, small commitment. An hour a week where the agenda is not solving known problems but exploring new questions. What problems could we be solving that we're not? What assumptions about our business could be wrong? What are our clients complaining about that we've normalized? These questions don't produce immediate ROI. They produce the ideas that produce ROI six months from now.
What This Means for Your Agency
Run a one-hour ideation session with your team this week. Give them a single question, something like "what's one thing we could do differently in how we onboard new clients that would make them dramatically more likely to refer?", and spend the first 30 minutes generating ideas without evaluation. Set a specific number target: aim for 30 ideas, including the bad ones. Then spend the second 30 minutes sorting and evaluating. The constraint of generating 30 ideas forces the team past the obvious answers into more interesting territory.
Track your personal ideaflow for two weeks. Keep a running list of every idea you have about your business, about marketing, hiring, client service, operations, anything. Don't filter for practicality. Just capture volume. At the end of two weeks, review the list and count how many ideas you generated. That number is your baseline ideaflow. The goal of any innovation practice is to increase it.
Part 2 of the Jeremy Utley conversation goes into the specific cultures and structures that support continuous innovation, how to build an environment where ideaflow is high and the best ideas surface and get tested.
The Bottom Line
Jeremy Utley's ideaflow framework gives insurance agency owners a genuinely practical handle on innovation: stop trying to produce great ideas, start producing more ideas. The quality that emerges from volume consistently outperforms the quality that comes from premature judgment. Build the culture and the practices that keep the flow moving, and watch your agency's problem-solving capacity compound in ways that incremental optimization never delivers.
Catch the full conversation:
Level up your agency:
Jeremy Utley is one of the world's leading experts on innovation, a faculty member at Stanford's d.school, and co-author of "Ideaflow: The Only Business Metric That Matters."
Listen to The Insurance Dudes Podcast
Get more strategies like this on our podcast. Available on all platforms.
Related Episodes
The Science of Getting Teams to Actually Perform: Seth Preus on Intrinsic Motivation and Accountability That Sticks
What Educational Consultant Melissa Dillon Teaches Insurance Agents About Redefining Failure
Brian Ahearn on Influence and Leadership — How Choosing Love Builds Lasting Insurance Agencies
From Network Marketing to 10 Medicare Policies a Week: Julian Chambers' Young Agent Success Formula
Building an Insurance Agency Worth Working For: Sethe Smith on Culture, Grit, and Real Talk