Building an Insurance Agency Worth Working For: Sethe Smith on Culture, Grit, and Real Talk
Hosts of The Insurance Dudes Podcast — 1,000+ episodes helping insurance agents build elite agencies
The most valuable agency owner conversations are the ones where the person across from you doesn't perform success. They just tell you what happened, including the parts that were embarrassing, expensive, or both. Sethe Smith, owner of the Sethe Smith Agency in Fort Wayne, Indiana, is that kind of conversation partner. His candor about the real difficulties of agency ownership, the hiring mistakes, the why-you-need-a-why moments, the sales staff retention problem that plagues almost every growing agency, is more useful than a hundred polished success narratives.
The Unglamorous Reality of Building from Scratch
Sethe Smith didn't inherit a book of business or a team. He built from scratch, which means every early lesson cost him money or time that he couldn't easily spare. The "why" question, what drives you to keep going when the rational response would be to stop, isn't motivational poster material in his framing. It's practical. Agents who haven't answered it clearly fail during the hard stretches that every scratch agency owner experiences. The ones who have answered it keep dialing.
His stories from the agency trenches are the kind that make audiences simultaneously wince and nod, because they've been there too, or can see exactly how they'd end up there without the guardrails that experience provides. The office incidents he describes (yes, including the unforgettable ones) aren't just entertainment, they're reminders that running an agency involves real humans doing real things in real circumstances, and that the best-run operations have seen every version of chaos and built processes that survive it.
The hiring challenge is where Sethe's experience is most directly instructive. Insurance sales is a high-attrition profession. The gap between the number of people who say they can sell and the number who actually can is enormous. Most agency owners make the same sequence of mistakes: hire fast, hope they perform, get disappointed, repeat. Sethe worked through that cycle enough times to build a different model, one that screens more rigorously, onboards more intentionally, and has honest performance conversations earlier.
His insight about the relationship between having a clear "why" and retaining good people is one that most agency management literature misses. Producers who understand why they're doing the work, who have connected their production goals to something that genuinely matters to them, sustain performance through hard weeks when quota-motivated producers quit. The agency owner who helps their people discover and articulate their why isn't being soft. They're building retention infrastructure.
The Real Talk on Insurance Agency Hiring
Most hiring problems are screening problems. Sethe's experience is consistent with what every experienced hiring manager in insurance eventually figures out: the producers who fail usually failed a screen that wasn't rigorous enough to catch it. Work ethic assessment, phone presence testing, commission tolerance, these screens exist for a reason. Using them consistently reduces the expensive surprise of a 90-day underperformer.
Early performance conversations prevent late-stage failures. The instinct to give a struggling new hire "more time" is often more about the hiring manager's discomfort with the conversation than the producer's likelihood of turning it around. Sethe's approach is to have direct, specific performance conversations early, week three, not month three, so there's still time to either course-correct or make a clean exit before the relationship has accumulated enough sunk cost to cloud the judgment.
Culture protects against attrition more than compensation does. Sethe's observation is one of the most consistently validated findings in agency management: the producers who leave for a $10,000 salary difference were already leaving. The ones who stay do so because they're part of something that matters to them, a team they respect, a leader they trust, a mission they can explain. Compensation has to be fair, but it's rarely the primary retention driver.
The "why" conversation is a management tool. Helping each team member articulate what they're working toward, not as a corporate exercise, but as a genuine one-on-one investment in their development, is one of the most practical things a manager can do for retention. When you know what each person on your team actually cares about, you can recognize their progress in terms that resonate with them specifically.
Failure is data, not verdict. Sethe is explicit that the setbacks he's had in agency ownership, the bad hires, the failed campaigns, the systems that didn't work, were the most instructive periods of his development. The agency owners who treat failure as permanent rather than informational tend to become either overly cautious or chronically repetitive in their mistakes.
What This Means for Your Agency
This week, have one genuine "why" conversation with each of your producers. Not a performance review. A real conversation: why did you get into this? What are you working toward? What would achieving your production goals actually make possible for you? Listen carefully. The answers will tell you more about their motivation and retention risk than any performance metric.
Then look at your 30-day new hire process. What structure do you actually provide in the first month? If the answer is "I show them around, get them set up, and hope they figure it out," that's your retention problem. Build a week-by-week milestone document for new producers, specific skills to develop, specific metrics to hit, specific conversations to have with the manager. New producers who feel equipped and supported don't quit.
The Bottom Line
Sethe Smith's agency runs the way it does because he paid attention to the failures as carefully as the wins, and built processes that learn from both. That orientation toward honest self-assessment, combined with genuine investment in his team's development, is the foundation of an agency that performs consistently rather than just occasionally.
Catch the full conversation:
Level up your agency:
Listen to The Insurance Dudes Podcast
Get more strategies like this on our podcast. Available on all platforms.
Related Episodes
Eric Yaverbaum's Playbook for Building Accountability Into a Flexible Insurance Agency Culture
Eric Yaverbaum on Why the Rigid Insurance Agency Workplace Is Losing the Talent War
From Law Enforcement to Insurance Sales: How Career Changers Crush It in P&C
Stop Hiring Out of Desperation: The 5-Step Insurance Agency Hiring System That Actually Works
The Science of Getting Teams to Actually Perform: Seth Preus on Intrinsic Motivation and Accountability That Sticks