Why Hiring Outside the Insurance Industry Is David Carothers' Secret Weapon for Agency Growth

Insurance agents who hire other insurance agents think they're getting a head start. They're often getting someone else's bad habits, price-shopping instincts, and resistance to learning new ways. David Carothers, commercial insurance agency owner in Tampa and one of the most direct voices in the industry, has built something different by doing what most agency owners are afraid to try: hiring people who have never sold insurance a day in their lives. The results are hard to argue with.

From Macaroni and Cheese to Market Domination

David Carothers is not someone who arrived in insurance with a trust fund, a mentor, and a clear map. He started from a college baseball career that ended, a stint in retail that taught him about customers and hustle, and a genuinely uncertain financial period that he describes with the kind of candor that makes his success feel earned rather than inevitable.

What he figured out early, and this is the insight that drives everything else he does, is that the insurance industry's conventional wisdom about hiring is backward. The conventional wisdom says: hire people who know insurance, they'll be productive faster, they'll need less training, they'll understand the business. David's experience showed him the opposite. People who already know insurance often come with habits that undermine the specific culture and approach he was building. They arrive with their own sales scripts, their own shortcuts, and their own opinions about how things should be done, opinions that may have worked somewhere else but conflict with what he was building.

So he started hiring from outside. Baseball coaches, retail managers, teachers, military veterans, people who could be trained from scratch on the technical side of commercial insurance, but who brought fresh energy, genuine coachability, and work ethics shaped by competitive or service-oriented environments. He invested in the training infrastructure required to actually develop these people into producers. And he built a culture that rewarded the characteristics he cared about, persistence, creativity within constraints, and a genuine orientation toward client outcomes, rather than assuming prior experience would carry the day.

The result is a commercial insurance agency in Tampa that competes effectively against much larger organizations, maintains a distinctive culture, and produces at a level that has made David one of the more interesting voices in the industry on questions of talent development and agency leadership.

The Outside-Hire Playbook

Start with character, train on content. David's screening process is explicitly designed to identify character before it ever assesses insurance knowledge. Work ethic, intellectual curiosity, coachability, and the kind of self-belief that allows someone to hear "no" fifty times and still make call fifty-one, these are the things he's looking for. Commercial insurance knowledge is a six-month training program. Character is twenty or thirty years of lived experience.

Build real training infrastructure. The reason most agencies don't hire outside the industry is that they don't have the training infrastructure to onboard someone with zero industry experience. David built it, role plays, scripts, structured learning progressions, mentorship pairings. If you want the benefits of fresh talent, you have to invest in developing that talent. There's no shortcut.

Culture is a competitive weapon. The agents who want to leave and join David's agency already know what it stands for. His culture is visible, discussed openly, and consistently executed. This means that when he's recruiting, he's not just competing on compensation, he's offering a compelling environment that self-selects for the kind of people who will thrive there. The culture that repels some candidates is protecting you from the wrong hires.

Commercial lines rewards deep specialization. David's Tampa agency doesn't try to write everything. He knows the commercial verticals he's strong in, the client profiles he can serve exceptionally well, and the coverage structures that produce the best outcomes for his clients. That specialization is what allows him to compete with larger agencies that have more carriers and more resources but less focused expertise.

Self-belief over the bank account. One of the most memorable things David says is that building this agency required him to believe in himself when his bank account was actively arguing otherwise. The period between starting and building enough book to be financially stable is the valley of death for most agency owners. His message is blunt: you have to outlast it, and you have to do it on conviction because the evidence isn't there yet.

What This Means for Your Agency

Look at your last five hires. How many came from within the insurance industry? How many are still with you? If you're seeing a pattern of industry hires who bring baggage along with their experience, bad habits, price-shopping tendencies, resistance to your processes, it may be time to reconsider where you're fishing for talent.

Run an experiment: post a producer role this month without requiring insurance experience. Instead of listing licenses and product knowledge as requirements, list the character attributes you actually care about. Coachable, competitive, service-oriented, persistent. See what the applicant pool looks like. You might be surprised.

Then honestly assess your onboarding. If you brought in a sharp person with zero insurance background tomorrow, could you actually develop them into a productive producer? If the answer is no, building that capability is a higher-leverage investment than most marketing spend.

The Bottom Line

David Carothers didn't build his agency the conventional way, and that's exactly why it works. Hiring outside the industry is uncomfortable and initially more work. It's also how you build a team that actually embodies the culture you're trying to create, rather than inheriting the culture of whoever trained them last.

---

Catch the full conversation:

• Listen on Spotify
• Listen on Apple Podcasts
• Watch on YouTube

Level up your agency:

• The Million Dollar Agency Book
• Join Agent Elite on Skool
• Book a Free Strategy Call
• TheIDudes.com